So, as a (pretty much) lifelong Triumph rider/afficiando, I would say this. I have owned a '79 Bonneville for the last 27 years - as a toy and a talking-point it cannot be beaten and I cannot imagine ever giving it up. I have owned quite a few bikes over the years too, including a number of Hinckley Triumphs - an early Speed Triple, a T595 (beautiful bike) and a Daytona 955i (a better bike, but not as beautiful as the T595). I also own a '97 VFR...
In my opinion, the VFR is the best bike I've ever owned and ridden and I would now choose it over a Triumph (almost) every day of the week - and that's not the easiest thing for a Triumph man to say.
The only real alternative is surely a later, lower-mileage VFR750...